<img alt="" src="https://secure.wire0poor.com/215720.png" style="display:none;">
Request a Demo Sign In
May 26, 2021

Local Marketing Insider #008 // How to Analyze Your Competitor's Reputation in 6 Steps

Learn the six data points you should collect to understand your competitor's online reputation and reputation strategy. Use this to determine how to beat competitors in local search.

I was wondering about this question - how good does your online reputation really need to be? How do you know how much time and money to put into a strategy for a specific industry and location? The answer - look to the competition. 

Putting customer experience aside for the moment, an effective reputation management strategy aims to bring in more customers by showing up at the top of local search results for relevant, high intent keywords. 

As a result, you don’t necessarily need a 5.0 and 1,000 reviews. You need to outperform the local competition. 

Understanding the landscape in your industry/city will give you a baseline level of performance to compare your reputation against. With this, you can set appropriate goals for your business.

Competitor Reputation Analysis Exercise

Starting with these seven questions, collect reputation information on relevant local competitors. 

Tip: Collect data using an incognito browser window to remove search history that may bias the results.

1. Identify competitor search rank

Where does the competition show up in the Map Pack for your target product/service keyword and geo?


1. Start with your business’s primary category and then test for ranking differences based on subcategories and related keywords.

Find your primary category at business.google.com:


Find your subcategories:


2. Record your competitor’s rank for each of these terms compared to your business.

3. Add “near me” and “best of” modifiers to core category searches and note any differences.

Go deeper: Pick test spots at four different points in the area surrounding your store to test for differences.

You can use Local Falcon to view how your rankings vary by location.

Also within your Google My Business account (business.google.com) under “Insights” you can see “Direction requests”. 

Look to see if you have strong competition in underperforming regions.


2. Determine lifetime and monthly competitor review volume

How many reviews (volume) and how often your competitors get reviews (frequency) are influential on local search rankings.

Take note of how many reviews each competitor has amassed in its lifetime (number displayed on GMB) and over the prior three months. To collect the latter you will need to count manually.

Make sure to sort by “Newest”, as Google defaults to sorting by “Most relevant”.


3. Find star rating

This one is pretty self-explanatory, make note of their star rating.


4. Calculate response percentage

What percentage of reviews are they responding to? It will make sense to collect this info while counting review volume for the past 90 days. 

As a benchmark, we recommend a 100% response rate.

5. Do competitor review responses use personalization, SEO keywords?

If responding, are they using personalization and SEO keywords in their responses? If yes, your competitor likely has trained staff or a vendor managing its review response. 

In this context:

Personalization = customer name, references to specific content in review

SEO keywords = business name, location, products/services

Note this as a “yes” or “no”.


6. Explore competitor activity on review sites other than Google

The last step, complete a brand search for each of your selected competitors. Make note of which sites show up and the competitor’s activity on each. Use this information to identify if you are underperforming on any of these sites. 


Recommendation: In 2020, 64% of all reviews managed by our team were on Google. Generally, Google should be your primary review target because of the positive impact search rankings can have on your business. But, if you’re lagging way behind a specific competitor on another site and that property is getting good exposure on your target searches, consider moving some resources to improve your reputation/activity level on that site.

To sum it up: 6 steps to analyze competitor reputation

  1. Competitor rankings by primary category keyword
    • Rankings by subcategory and related keywords
    • “Near me” and “best of” searches
  2. Lifetime review volume
    • Review volume last 3 months
  3. Rating
  4. Percentage of reviews responded to (last 3 months)
  5. Personalization and SEO in responses
  6. Competitor activity on other review sites
    • Find with branded search

When complete, you will have a well-rounded view of your competitor’s reputation and reputation strategy, establishing a solid baseline to helping determine what reputation presence you need to compete in local search for your specific location and industry. 

Thanks for reading Local Marketing Insider. If you think answering the question “how good does my business’s reputation need to be” will be helpful, start by grabbing this competitor analysis spreadsheet. I’ve created a template from the information explained above to give you a head start.


If you enjoyed this issue please share it with friends or colleagues.

See you in 2 weeks - Jake, Marketing @Widewail



Jake Hughes

I’m the Director of Marketing here at Widewail, as well as a husband and new dad outside the office. I'm in Vermont by way of Boston, where I grew the CarGurus YouTube channel from 0 to 100k subscribers. I love the outdoors and hate to be hot, so I’m doing just fine in the arctic Vermont we call home. Fun fact: I met my wife on the shuttle bus at Baltimore airport. Thanks for reading Widewail’s content!

U3GM Blog Post Comments

Other posts you might be interested in

The Changing Face of Customer Service

4 min read | November 12, 2018
How can you stay competitive as customer service changes? Read our advice on how to up your stakes with online reputation management.
Jane Garfinkel Product Manager

Mastering Residential Reputation Management - Decoding Multifamily Podcast

4 min read | May 13, 2024
Up your reputation management game with expert insights on responding to reviews, leveraging positive feedback and using technology to stand out in the competitive...
Dave Pye Director of Search

How to Repair Your Company's Online Reputation Performance

9 min read | December 20, 2023
Learn about the metrics that contribute to your company's online reputation performance and use these strategies to manage or repair how you score.
Jake Hughes Director of Marketing

Local Marketing Insider

Bite-sized, to-the-point, trend-driven local marketing stories and tactics.