<img alt="" src="https://secure.wire0poor.com/215720.png" style="display:none;">
Request a Demo Sign In
May 12, 2025

Speed, Trust & Follow-Through: What 1M Resident Reviews Reveal in 2025

Explore key takeaways from 1M reviews in Widewail’s 2025 Voice of the Resident Report—and how the multifamily resident experience is evolving.

Residents aren’t holding back in 2025.

They’re calling out missed promises, praising fast fixes, and spelling out exactly where communities fall short. 

Surface-level feedback has given way to sharper, more specific reviews—naming names, tracking timelines, and expecting results.

Widewail’s 2025 Voice of the Resident Report dives into thousands of resident reviews to reveal what matters most across the renter journey. From maintenance requests to move-in expectations, this year’s data tells a clear story: Speed, trust, and follow-through are no longer nice-to-haves. They’re non-negotiable.

Here are the 3 biggest takeaways from the report:

Biggest Storylines Voice of the Resident

1. Fast and Coordinated Service Is the New Baseline

Fast service isn’t impressive anymore—it’s expected.

Same-day fixes, real-time updates, and seamless coordination across teams have become the standard, especially during the maintenance stage. 

Residents even mention turnaround times in their positive reviews, with phrases like “within an hour,” “same day,” and “24-hour response” popping up more frequently than ever.

On the flip side, maintenance complaints are rising. Negative maintenance sentiment climbed +6.3% YoY, with timing—not just repair quality—driving the frustration.

Another shift? Management is now seen as the driver of speed. Positive mentions of office teams in maintenance reviews jumped +5% YoY, showing that residents credit leadership for making fast service happen.

Why it matters:

Residents expect same-day fixes and real-time updates as part of the deal. Falling short here sends a message (fair or not) that your community isn’t well-managed.

But it’s not just about the maintenance crew moving quickly. Residents are increasingly giving credit (or blame) to management for how things are coordinated. This year, positive management mentions in maintenance reviews went up 5%, showing that residents see the on-site team as the drivers of speed.

When residents feel like everyone’s aligned and moving together, they stick around. When they don’t, they start looking for a community that is.

2. Leasing Promises Are Breaking Trust Before Move-In

Move-in isn’t just a logistical handoff anymore: it’s a critical trust moment. Naturally, residents are frustrated when what they’re promised during leasing doesn’t match what they experience upon arrival. This year we saw:

  • A 7.9% increase in move-in maintenance complaints
  • Unit condition issues up 84% more than average in negative reviews
  • Cleanliness complaints up 12%
  • Pest issues rising 13%

Residents aren’t vague about it either. They’re quoting promises made during tours and pointing out when reality doesn’t match:

“The leasing agent said it’d be fixed by the 1st.”
“My apartment looks nothing like the unit I toured.”
“Appliances were missing when I moved in, and no one followed up.”

These aren’t simple maintenance slip-ups. They’re communication breakdowns that erode trust before the first rent check is even due.

Why it matters:

First impressions stick.

A broken promise at move-in doesn’t just annoy your new resident, it plants a seed of doubt. An early breach of trust makes every future interaction harder. You’ll have to work twice as hard to regain lost confidence, even if your service improves later.

There’s also a real business impact. Unhappy move-ins:

  • Drive churn.
  • Generate negative reviews when your community is most visible.
  • Create friction that hurts referrals and renewals.

To fix this, leasing and operations teams must stay in lockstep. It’s not enough to “hand off” a new resident. Every promise made during the sales process needs to be tracked, verified, and followed through before the resident walks through their new front door.

3. Reviews Are Getting More Detailed, Specific, and Strategic

Residents are leveling up their feedback game.

In 2025, reviews read more like service logs, complete with team member names, timelines, and specific outcomes.

Some key shifts from the data: (positive mentions, YoY)

  • Tour Guide mentions: +18.5%
  • Property Manager mentions: +12.9%
  • Customer Service mentions: +8%
  • Generic “staff” mentions: down -5.2%

Even negative feedback has evolved and gotten more specific. While rent complaints during renewal dropped 27%, frustration with unclear fees spiked 21%. Cleanliness and pest issues are also on the rise, often linked to inconsistent onsite presence.

Residents are being deliberate. They’re not just venting—they’re documenting. And they expect action.

Why it matters:

Residents have raised the bar for how they give feedback. Reviews aren’t casual comments anymore—they’re detailed records of what happened, who was involved, and whether the community followed through.

This shift cuts both ways:

  • Positive reviews highlight specific wins: individual team members, fast service, and smooth communication.
  • Negative reviews focus on clear failures: fees, cleanliness, and maintenance consistency. 

Residents are showing you exactly where your processes break down. But by being so specific, they’re also raising expectations for how precisely you respond.

If a resident spends time outlining their issue in detail, they expect you to:

  • Acknowledge their feedback thoughtfully
  • Fix the problem without forcing them to repeat themselves
  • Demonstrate clear follow-through

In short: detailed reviews demand detailed service.

Communities that treat these reviews like service tickets will have an edge—not just in online reputation, but in actual resident experience.

The Bottom Line: Expectations Are Higher Than Ever

The 2025 Voice of the Resident data leaves no doubt: Speed, trust, and follow-through are non-negotiable.

Residents know what they were promised. They’re paying attention. And they’re not afraid to speak up, or move out if the experience falls short.

The communities that stand out won’t just react quickly when things go wrong.
They’ll stay consistent, keep communication clear, and make sure leasing, operations, and service teams are working as one, from the first tour to lease renewal.

Want the full picture of what residents are saying at every stage of their journey? Download the full (free) Voice of the Resident Report below.

Explore the Full Report

Emily Keenan

Originally from Scarborough, Maine, I moved to Vermont after graduating from St. Lawrence University, where I received my BA in English and Spanish. I have always been interested in writing and communication, which is what initially drew me to the Review Response Specialist position at Widewail. In my spare time, I can be found reading, playing electric guitar, or strolling/biking around one of Burlington’s many scenic trails. I always welcome the opportunity to talk about my work, and invite anyone with questions or comments to reach out or connect with me on LinkedIn.

U3GM Blog Post Comments

Other posts you might be interested in

How Car Dealers Can Bounce Back From A 1-Star Crisis

7 min read | May 29, 2025
6 steps to address a negative review event and turn it into an opportunity to improve operations, customer communication, and long-term trust.
Ellie Guyon Review Response Specialist

How to Nest Department Listings on Google My Business

12 min read | May 23, 2025
In this article, we will discuss which nesting options your business qualifies for, how to create additional pages and the benefits of doing so.
Jane Garfinkel Product Manager

Top Automotive Review Sites Every Dealership Should Prioritize in 2025

10 min read | May 7, 2025
Learn which automotive review sites influence car buyers and how to manage them effectively.
Kyle Gagnon Kyle Gagnon

Local Marketing Insider

Bite-sized, to-the-point, trend-driven local marketing stories and tactics.