Request a Demo Sign In

Best Buick GMC Dealerships in Indianapolis: The View of the Customer

The 5 best Buick GMC stores in the Indianapolis metro, ranked from 9 on what their own customers said in public Google reviews this year: how they rate them, how many are commenting, whether the store answers, and how often customers leave frustrated.

Key takeaways

  • No Buick GMC dealer in the area holds an A this month; York Chevrolet Buick GMC leads with a B.
  • York Chevrolet Buick GMC is gaining share of the area's Buick GMC conversation this year.
  • Professionalism is the most common cause of frustration, at 2 of 5 stores.
  • Every store in the area replies to at least an average share of its reviews.

Graded on what customers actually said

Most "best dealership" lists rank on star rating alone. A 4.8 with 40 reviews and a 4.8 with 4,000 reviews are not the same store, and neither number tells you whether the dealership answers when something goes wrong. The Widewail Index reads every public Google review for the 9 Buick GMC dealers in the Indianapolis metro and grades each one on four things.

Customer RatingStar rating, weighted by volume
Comment ActivityHow many customers write about the store each month
ResponsivenessShare of reviews that get an owner reply
FrustrationShare of reviews describing a bad experience. Lower is better.
A90–100 ExceptionalB80–89 StrongC70–79 AverageD60–69 Below averageFUnder 60

Each input is ranked against every franchise dealer in the country, combined into one score, and converted to a letter. Grades refresh monthly and cannot be purchased.

The 5 best Buick GMC dealers in Indianapolis, ranked from 9

Ordered by customer health score, 2026 year to date.

1OF 5

York Chevrolet Buick GMC

Greencastle, IN
BStrongTop 10% nationally

Against franchise dealers nationally: customer rating top 25%, comment activity above average, responsiveness top 25%, frustration top 25% (a higher tier means fewer frustrated customers). Customers most often praise wait times. Valet is what most often causes frustration.

Customer rating Top 25%Comment activity Above avgResponsiveness Top 25%Frustration Top 25%Share of voice Gaining
Often praisedWait times
Causes frustrationValet
2OF 5

Stoops Buick GMC

Plainfield, IN
BStrongTop 25% nationally

Against franchise dealers nationally: customer rating above average, comment activity above average, responsiveness top 25%, frustration below average (a higher tier means fewer frustrated customers). Customers most often praise wait times. Maintenance and repair is what most often causes frustration.

Customer rating Above avgComment activity Above avgResponsiveness Top 25%Frustration Below avgShare of voice Holding
Often praisedWait times
Causes frustrationMaintenance and repair
3OF 5

Ed Martin Buick GMC of Anderson

Anderson, IN
BStrongTop 25% nationally

Against franchise dealers nationally: customer rating below average, comment activity below average, responsiveness top 25%, frustration above average (a higher tier means fewer frustrated customers). Customers most often praise management. Cleanliness is what most often causes frustration.

Customer rating Below avgComment activity Below avgResponsiveness Top 25%Frustration Above avgShare of voice Holding
Often praisedManagement
Causes frustrationCleanliness
4OF 5

Andy Mohr Buick GMC

Fishers, IN
BStrongTop half nationally

Against franchise dealers nationally: customer rating below average, comment activity above average, responsiveness above average, frustration bottom 25% (a higher tier means fewer frustrated customers). Customers most often praise inventory. Professionalism is what most often causes frustration.

Customer rating Below avgComment activity Above avgResponsiveness Above avgFrustration Bottom 25%Share of voice Losing
Often praisedInventory
Causes frustrationProfessionalism
5OF 5

Ed Martin Buick GMC

Carmel, IN
BStrongTop half nationally

Against franchise dealers nationally: customer rating bottom 25%, comment activity below average, responsiveness top 25%, frustration bottom 25% (a higher tier means fewer frustrated customers). Customers most often praise inventory. Professionalism is what most often causes frustration.

Customer rating Bottom 25%Comment activity Below avgResponsiveness Top 25%Frustration Bottom 25%Share of voice Holding
Often praisedInventory
Causes frustrationProfessionalism

Frequently asked

What is the best Buick GMC dealership in Indianapolis?

York Chevrolet Buick GMC in Greencastle ranks first among 9 Buick GMC dealers in the Indianapolis metro on the Widewail Index for 2026, with a customer health score grade of B. No Buick GMC dealer in the metro holds an A this month.

How are Indianapolis Buick GMC dealerships ranked?

Each dealership is scored on four inputs from public Google reviews, 2026 year to date: customer rating, comment activity, responsiveness, and frustration. Inputs are ranked against every franchise dealer nationally, combined into one customer health score, and shown as a letter grade from A to F. Grades refresh monthly and cannot be purchased.

Which Buick GMC dealers in Indianapolis are gaining ground?

York Chevrolet Buick GMC accounts for a larger share of the metro's Buick GMC reviews this year than over its lifetime.

How many Buick GMC dealers in Indianapolis were considered, and what does it take to make the list?

9 Buick GMC dealers in the Indianapolis metro were assessed and 5 made the list. Every store on it holds a B or better on the Widewail Index customer health score, and every store is at least above average on responsiveness. Stores that did not make it are not named; their management teams can request a free scorecard showing the gap on each input.

Does a higher grade mean lower prices?

No. The grade measures what customers say in public reviews, not transaction prices. Pricing appears only as a sentiment topic, when customers raise it more or less often than at a typical Buick GMC dealer. Always get an out-the-door price in writing.

Not on this list?

9 Buick GMC dealers were considered. 5 made it. Here's what it takes.

Every store on this list holds a B or better on the Widewail Index customer health score, and the weakest store on the list still clears these bars against every franchise dealer in the country:

Customer rating Bottom 25%Comment activity Below averageResponsiveness Above averageFrustration Bottom 25%

Would your store make this list?

Enter what you know about your Google reviews this year. Each input is placed against every franchise dealer in the country and compared with the bar above.

Fill in any input to see where it lands.

What's in your scorecard

The same report Widewail delivers to dealer groups every quarter, built for your store from the Widewail Index, with a 20-minute analyst walkthrough for your GM and department heads.

  • Reputation Health Score, exact, and your rank among Indianapolis Buick GMC dealers •• / 100 · rank •• of 9
  • Monthly rating vs. benchmark •.•• · +•.•%
  • Monthly review volume vs. benchmark •• / mo · +••%
  • Response rate vs. benchmark ••% · ••.•%
  • Negativity percent vs. benchmark •.•% · ••.•%
  • Prioritized topics for the GM •••• · •••• ••••• · •••••
  • All 25 topics, positive and negative, vs. benchmark 25 × 4 values
  • The gap between your store and this list, input by input4 gaps
Analyst walkthrough. How the score is calculated, how topic analysis works, and what would move your store onto this list.

And for the stores on it: keep the spot.

Comment activity is one of the four inputs, and the one a management team controls fastest. See what Widewail's review generation would do for a store your size.

See how many reviews you could generate with Widewail

Comment activity is one of the four inputs behind every grade on this list, and the one a management team can change fastest. Enter your store's monthly transactions.

Enter either number to see the estimate.

How Widewail moves each measure on this page

Moves: Comment Activity

Signal

Review generation, private surveys and video testimonials, sent to every customer after a sale or service visit, so the customers who already chose you are the ones shoppers hear from.

18%of review requests converted at Cavender Auto Family; one store grew review volume 820% in 90 days.
Moves: Responsiveness

Response

Specialist-written replies to every review and social comment, delivered within 24 hours from one feed, including the negative ones shoppers read first.

5,622custom responses written in one year across seven Sloane Automotive locations.
Moves: Rating and Frustration

Customer Clarity

A monthly diagnosis of what's working, what's slipping, and who delivered it: staff performance by name, peer benchmarking from the Widewail Index, and ranked recommendations your managers can act on.

25 topicsclassified on every review, with the frustration drivers behind this page's tiers named and prioritized.