Top dealer groups struggle with communication, but the real issue happens before customers even talk to staff.
View in browser
favicon
REV Newsletter - No background - Square

REV #048

The Call-Back Problem Is Bigger Than It Looks

By Jake Hughes

BY JAKE HUGHES

January 22nd, 2026

Welcome to the REV. A weekly briefing on what the Auto industry can learn about customer experience from millions of Google reviews. Every Thursday, we Rank, Explore & Visualize automotive reputation & sentiment data. 

 

Our latest quarterly research report analyzes 1.45M Google Reviews from 18,000 U.S. dealerships, revealing what customers are saying across the auto industry. Get your copy below:

Report: Q3 Voice of the Customer Report

 

Read online. Subscribe to REV

RANK

    Communication Follow-Up Is the Top Complaint, Even Among The Big Groups

      We looked at the Top 5 dealer groups with the highest share of negative reviews mentioning communication. These are large, centralized operations, and yet they still struggle to meet industry standards.

      REV #048 Table-1

      Across these 5 groups, the average is 55.9% of negative reviews mentioning communication, well above the already-high industry benchmark of 49.3%. Even the “best” performer in this set still has more than half of its negative reviews tied to communication.

       

      Takeaway: Communication breakdowns are showing up consistently and at scale, even in groups with resources, tech, and structure on paper.

       

      See the full analysis of communication trends across the Top 150 auto groups, including review samples and a look at what the highest-performing groups are doing right, in the Q3 Voice of the Customer Report.

      EXPLORE

      This Is a Process Miss, Not a People Problem

        When we compare communication to other service signals, the disconnect becomes obvious.


        Negative mentions of professionalism stay low—between 1.3% and 4.1%. When customers actually reach someone, the interaction is rarely the problem.


        The issue is what happens before that.


        Most communication complaints aren’t about tone or attitude. They’re about silence: no call back, no update, no follow-through. That’s why the same language keeps appearing in reviews, repeated across brands and markets: “No one called me back.”


        Management sentiment adds another layer. Between 21% and 28% of negative reviews in these groups also reference management. These misses aren’t isolated mistakes; they’re symptoms of processes that aren’t consistently owned or tracked.


        Operationally, this pattern compounds quickly. The average service department misses roughly 158 appointment-related calls per month. 


        That’s how communication becomes the top negative theme at the group level. Not through a single breakdown, but through repeated, low-visibility misses that feel small in the moment and structural in hindsight.


        What dealers need to focus on: missed call rate, call-back compliance, and time-to-response. When those aren’t measured, communication breakdowns don’t register as urgent. They only show up later, in reviews.

        VISUALIZE

        Top 5 Auto Groups With the Most Communication Negativity

          REV #048 Chart-1

          McGovern Automotive Group was already a leader—but they wanted to see how far their digital reputation could go.

           

          Rather than sticking with standard engagement, they revamped their feedback process to increase transparency and build real customer trust.

           

          The payoff: review volume now exceeds the industry average by 252%, and they rank #10 on the Top 150 Dealer Groups list.

           

          See how a top-tier group took their reputation to the next level in the full case study. 

          See you next week - Jake, Marketing @Widewail

          Jake_Headshot_Widewail_Branded

          Explore more Data & Insights. Book at Widewail Demo.

          REV Newsletter - Grey – 1

          Widewail, 44 Lakeside Ave, #114, Burlington, VT 05401, USA

          Unsubscribe